Circe Novel by Madeleine Miller: A New Voice from Myth for High School Students

, ,
Watercolor illustration of Circe standing on her island, looking thoughtfully at the sea, inspired by Madeleine Miller’s Circe novel.

When high school classes finish reading Homer’s Odyssey, Circe often lingers in the background: the sorceress who turns Odysseus’ men into pigs. Her role is brief yet powerful, leaving young readers intrigued and wanting to know more. This is where a contemporary reading can step in: Circe novel (2018), written by classics teacher Madeleine Miller, who revisits and reinterprets the Homeric figure with extraordinary sensitivity. I recently read this book myself, and it completely captivated me, so I decided to share it with my students—it won them over as well, sparking excellent opportunities for dialogue and reflection.

Miller does not simply modernize a myth. She builds a story grounded in careful classical research, while choosing to explore Circe’s most intimate and human dimensions. The result is a narrative that captivates, moves, and—above all—speaks to today’s learners.

Circe Novel: A Plot That Expands the Epic

Circe, daughter of the sun god Helios and the nymph Perse, grows up in a divine world where she never feels at home. Her “harsh” voice, judged a flaw among immortals, instead brings her closer to mortals, toward whom she feels drawn from the very beginning.

The encounter with Prometheus, punished for giving fire to humankind, marks her first break with the world of the gods. Later, her love for the mortal Glaucus and the discovery of her magical powers lead her to life-changing choices, including the transformation of Scylla into the monster of legend.

Banished to the island of Aiaia, Circe creates a solitary yet creative existence made of herbs, spells, and tame animals. Here she welcomes castaways and travelers: Daedalus, Odysseus, and later Penelope and Telemachus. Her relationship with the Achaean hero, in particular, offers a new vision of him: no longer just the cunning figure celebrated by Homer, but a man also marked by cruelty and ruthless calculation, as later traditions often portrayed him.

The novel closes with a surprising choice: after experiencing love, pain, motherhood, and solitude, Circe embraces mortality as the most authentic form of life—one that gives meaning to time and value to experience.

Themes of the Circe Novel for Classroom Reflection

Circe novel is an ideal text for high school because it blends myth with contemporary concerns while raising universal, thought-provoking themes:

1. The gap between gods and humans

Miller highlights how the gods never truly know pain or loss—experiences that give mortal life depth and meaning. Circe stands apart from the Olympians: she undergoes something alien to them—growth, change. This transformation is not physical, but interior. She learns to let go of her son, to come to terms with her past, and to desire a peaceful, mutable human life. In this mutable nature lies her essence: she understands that time and change are needed to truly hold and value people and experiences. Immortals, untouched by pain and death, cannot grasp this. Exploring this theme in class can spark deep and rewarding discussions.

“I thought once that gods are the opposite of death, but I see now they are more dead than anything, for they are unchanging, and can hold nothing in their hands.”

2. Change, humanity, and femininity

Circe, the goddess with the “harsh” voice, is a figure in constant transformation, unlike the static gods around her. Her greatest achievement is not divine power, but the ability to change and grow—even to the point of embracing mortality. She becomes “human” in the deepest sense. Readers can empathize with her doubts, fragility, and strength. For learners, Circe offers a chance to reflect on what defines human greatness and dignity. Finally, much can be said about Circe as a “woman.” Not surprisingly, critics have often read the Circe novel as a feminist work. Claire Messud of The New York Times, for example, approved of its feminist themes and praised the story as a “highly psychologized, redemptive and ultimately exculpatory account” of Circe’s character. The novel highlights the feminine experience through the remarkable introspection Miller gives her protagonist; the narrative is anchored in her emotional life as a woman, allowing readers to explore themes such as justice, the perception of female power, relationships, and motherhood.

3. The rewriting of Odysseus

The Homeric hero appears in a new light—less idealized, closer to the complexity of later traditions. From a philological and methodological standpoint, this is fascinating: analyzing Miller’s portrayal and tracing it back to her cited sources allows learners to see that Homer’s voice is not the only one. Many parallel traditions exist, offering alternative perspectives and developments of characters we thought we knew.

Why High School Students Should Read Circe Novel

In short, Madeleine Miller—drawing on her classical background—offers a story rich in accurate mythological references, yet also accessible and engaging for young readers. The novel allows teachers and students to:

  • Enrich the reading of the Odyssey with a modern complement that deepens understanding of its characters and myths.
  • Start discussions on the relationship between gods and humans, the nature of power, and the importance of change.
  • Foster empathy: learners encounter a goddess who speaks their emotional language, who knows fragility, desire, and pain.

Circe novel stands out for the beauty of its prose and the depth of its portrayal of a character too often pushed to the margins. It tells the story of a woman-goddess who chooses to embrace her humanity fully.

For high school teachers, it can be a valuable resource: proof that ancient myths are not relics of the past, but living narratives that still speak of freedom, growth, and identity.

I hope this recommendation is useful! If you have read this novel and would like to share your thoughts, I would love to hear from you in the comments.

Warm regards, and happy teaching!

Chiara

A Note for Teachers

If you have already read the novel with your students or assigned it to them and are looking for a versatile, comprehensive final test, I recommend checking out this resource. It reviews all the themes explored in this article: 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top